Just one month in, optimism around CAR’s peace deal is fading

March 30, 2019, 1:48 pm

One month after a peace deal was signed to end the civil war, fighting continues in the Central African Republic, while the thorny issue of amnesty for militants has not been clearly resolved.

There is no doubt a peace deal could be transformative for the Central African Republic. Armed groups control 80% of the territory. Tens of thousands of people languish in internal displacement camps in the centre of the country.
About 1.2-million people are either refugees or internally displaced.

So there was cautious optimism last month when the parties agreed a new deal — the eighth since 2012 — in Khartoum under African Union auspices. But there are worrying signs that the peace deal is beginning to fray. Just this week reports surfaced of fighting in Basse Kotto province between Seleka from the Union for Peace in the Central African Republic on the one side, and anti-balaka on the other. 

When the mostly Muslim Seleka made their way toward Bangui in late 2012, they unleashed a new and brutal wave of violence against civilians. In late 2013, the Christian and animist anti-balaka militias began to organise counterattacks. But in those attacks, civilians also became the target. Both sides executed civilians, raped women and girls or took them as sex slaves, pillaged homes, and destroyed entire villages and neighbourhoods.

I’ve spent much of the past six years travelling across the country, interviewing victims and their family members, and meeting with leaders of many of the armed groups as they fractured, made alliances with former enemies, and tried to remake themselves as political parties. In all the conversations with these leaders, there was one constant refrain: “This isn’t our fault, so we should not be held accountable for what happened. If civilians suffered, then we should talk about reconciliation, not justice. Justice will only lead to more problems.”

This question of justice was crucial, if complicated, in Khartoum. A key sticking point was the question of amnesty, sought by almost all the groups. During the talks, one rebel spokesman told journalists plainly, “We must have amnesty to have peace.”

The accord itself was signed days before the draft was made public, fuelling speculation that the national government had offered broad amnesty or that prosecutions were to be frozen. In the end, the agreement was vague on next steps to ensure justice for serious human rights abuses, crimes against humanity and war crimes. It does not mention specific judicial processes or recent efforts to promote justice in the country.

Representatives of some of the armed groups told me that they believe this means an amnesty has been granted, even though the word is not mentioned. They consider establishment of a Truth, Justice, Reconciliation and Reparation Commission an alternative to criminal accountability.

But they are ignoring that the accord clearly recognises the role impunity has played in entrenching “cycles of violence.” This important point echoes the conclusions of the Bangui Forum, national consultations held from May 4 to 11 2015 that brought together more than 800 representatives of community and other non-governmental organisations, political parties, and armed groups from across the country. The forum stated that “no amnesty” would be tolerated for those responsible for and acting as accomplices in international crimes.

The establishment of a Truth Commission does not in any way prevent national and international judicial systems from doing their work. And much has already been accomplished.

Among the recent efforts has been the establishment of a new tribunal in the Central African Republic’s domestic court system to try war crimes and crimes against humanity. Known as the Special Criminal Court, it formally began operations in late 2018. The International Criminal Court (ICC) also has opened an investigation into crimes committed since August 2012. Late last year, the court arrested two leaders of the anti-balaka militias that were parties to the conflict, Alfred Yékatom and Patrice Edouard Ngaissona. The national judicial system continues to prosecute Seleka and anti-balaka leaders and fighters in criminal trials.

Peace dividends that can be gained from the deal are much needed. But so are fair and credible prosecutions of the worst crimes to help ensure that rampant abuses in the CAR, fuelled by the lack of accountability, are brought to an end.

The government and its international partners should make clear to the armed groups and to the civilians who have suffered since 2012 that a Truth Commission does not equal amnesty. They can do this by providing continued support for the national judiciary, the Special Criminal Court, and the ICC’s investigation and prosecution of grave crimes.



Written by: Lewis Mudge

Lewis Mudge is Central Africa Director at Human Rights Watch, focusing on Burundi, the Central African Republic, Cameroon, the Democratic Republic of Congo, and Rwanda. Before joining Human Rights Watch he was based in Goma, eastern Congo, as the field manager for Interactive Radio for Justice, an organisation dedicated to creating local radio programs that concentrated on International Criminal Court proceedings. He has lived in Africa for over 13 years, the last 9 of which have been focused on Central Africa. He has written several Human Rights Watch reports and his op-eds have appeared in major papers and news outlets, but his true love is field research and getting to understand the individual cost of human rights abuses. He has a Masters in International Politics from the University of London’s School of Oriental and African Studies.


Comments

generic viagra without subscription walmart <a href=" https://viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com# ">son takes viagra</a> [url=https://viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com#]how long does it take for viagra to work[/url] cousin taking care of viagra cock

Dec 7, 2019
first time using viagra <a href=" https://viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com# ">what can i expect the first time i take viagra</a> using viagra to treat ed

Dec 7, 2019
how much is viagra <a href=" https://viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com# ">viagra doses cabqiqmiqysyy</a> [url=https://viagrawithoutdoctorspres.com#]is generic viagra available in usa? mbrnufeqdpcgb[/url] viagra pros and cons

Dec 7, 2019
online pharmacy india <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">pharmacy mall online reviews</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]canadian online pharmacy cialis[/url] testosterone online pharmacy

Dec 7, 2019
precription drugs from canada <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">canada drugs direct futqchfauwzlw</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]publix pharmacy online dqyklxyanmiqu[/url] best online canadian pharmacy

Dec 7, 2019
cvs pharmacy online refill <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">online pharmacy reviews</a> non prescription online pharmacy reviews [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]indian pharmacy online shopping[/url]

Dec 7, 2019
u.s online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">mexican pharmacy online</a> non prescription online pharmacy reviews [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]nps online pharmacy[/url]

Dec 6, 2019
canadian pharmacies online <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">online pet pharmacy</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]cheap online pharmacy[/url] drugs from canada

Dec 6, 2019
canadian pharmacies online <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">discount pharmacy online elyfpryfmzkku</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]legit online pharmacy jgokqkzkumvgn[/url] canadian online pharmacy reviews

Dec 6, 2019
top online pharmacy india <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">u.s online pharmacy</a> roman online pharmacy reviews [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]best canadian online pharmacy[/url]

Dec 6, 2019
nps online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">online pharmacy discount code</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]best online canadian pharmacy[/url] online pharmacy prescription

Dec 6, 2019
pharmacy online usa <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">canada drugs review</a> top online pharmacy india [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]pharmacy technician class online[/url]

Dec 6, 2019
reliable online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">pharmacy online usa</a> canadian pharmacy generic viagra [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]discount pharmacy online[/url]

Dec 6, 2019
canadian pharmacy cialis <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">online pharmacy aqwctapvvvxmd</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]canadian pharmacy viagra whyltjzjmhjap[/url] walmart pharmacy refill online

Dec 6, 2019
online prescription <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">walgreens online pharmacy</a> online pharmacy [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]mexican pharmacy online[/url]

Dec 6, 2019
trust pharmacy online <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">cialis online pharmacy</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]canadian online pharmacy[/url] pharmacy mall online reviews

Dec 6, 2019
reputable canadian pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">pharmacy technician training online</a> online pharmacy [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]canadian pharmacies[/url]

Dec 6, 2019
online canadian pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">indian pharmacy online</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]roman online pharmacy reviews[/url] pharmacy tech online course

Dec 6, 2019
tramadol online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">canada drugs laws</a> online pharmacy adderall [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]rx pharmacy online[/url]

Dec 6, 2019
legit canadian online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">cvs pharmacy online refill</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]legal online pharmacy[/url] adderall online pharmacy

Dec 6, 2019
online pharmacy degree <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">best canadian pharmacy</a> canadian pharmacies online [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]canadian online pharmacy viagra[/url]

Dec 6, 2019
online pharmacy without scripts <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">mexican online pharmacy</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]walmart pharmacy refill online[/url] online pharmacy prescription

Dec 6, 2019
reputable canadian online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">vipps approved canadian online pharmacy</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]mexico pharmacy online[/url] online pharmacy usa

Dec 6, 2019
viagra online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">canadian online pharmacy reviews sqqeqcbdvlefy</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]india pharmacy online punsuoolhuhyo[/url] silkroad online pharmacy

Dec 6, 2019
canada pharmacy online <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">non prescription online pharmacy wsbhaqgiyhmsz</a> canada drugs reviews [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]online pharmacy no presc scqauadnojhyc[/url]

Dec 6, 2019
canada pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">trusted online pharmacy</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]canadian pharmacy[/url] canadian pharmacy review

Dec 6, 2019
va pharmacy online <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">publix pharmacy online</a> canada drugs [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]prescription drugs online[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
canada drugs laws <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">overseas online pharmacy no prescription</a> adderall online pharmacy [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]online pharmacy no prescription needed[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
best online non prescription pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">online pharmacy hydrocodone jtgcoigvjbnqy</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]uk online pharmacy pvqiadgspznim[/url] india online pharmacy

Dec 5, 2019
safe online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">discount pharmacy online</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]prescription drugs online[/url] kroger pharmacy online

Dec 5, 2019
online pharmacy no prescription needed <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">precription drugs from canada</a> best online non prescription pharmacy [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]watch tour de pharmacy online[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
testosterone online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">pharmacy online usa</a> oxfordhealth online pharmacy [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]mexico online pharmacy[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
online pharmacy free viagra samples <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">precription drugs from canada</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]canadian drugs[/url] pharmacy technician course online free

Dec 5, 2019
canadian pharmacies <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">wegmans online pharmacy</a> canada drugs online review [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]canadian online pharmacy[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
u.s online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">costco online pharmacy qocmtxplxmwmp</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]indian online pharmacy uxrkeanvaepmx[/url] canadian pharmacy generic viagra

Dec 5, 2019
online pharmacy in india <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">canada drugs coupon code</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]pharmacy online[/url] online prescription

Dec 5, 2019
canadian pharmacy online cialis <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">cvs pharmacy online</a> cvs pharmacy online application [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]us pharmacy online[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
pharmacy tech programs online <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">india online pharmacy</a> pharmacy mall online reviews

Dec 5, 2019
prescription drugs online <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">perscription drugs from canada</a> precription drugs from canada [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]canada drugs review[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
kaiser online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">online compounding pharmacy</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]canada drugs coupon[/url] india pharmacy online

Dec 5, 2019
online pharmacy usa <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">online pharmacy in india</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]uk online pharmacy[/url] prescription drugs from canada

Dec 5, 2019
trust pharmacy online <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">shopko online pharmacy</a> discount pharmacy online [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]online pharmacy viagra[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
cheap viagra online canadian pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">best online pharmacy</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]kroger pharmacy online[/url] pharmacy tech online

Dec 5, 2019
us pharmacy online <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">french pharmacy online</a> pharmacy technician class online [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]pharmacy tech school online[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
pharmacy online usa <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">buy drugs from canada mvskzqhijvcvu</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]my canadian pharmacy huezreihevfqr[/url] п»їcanadian pharmacy online

Dec 5, 2019
online pharmacy usa <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">canadian pharmacy review</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]india online pharmacy[/url] canadian online pharmacy viagra

Dec 5, 2019
reputable canadian pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">pharmacy technician class online</a> canadian pharmacy generic viagra [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]pharmacy mall online reviews[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
online pharmacy school <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">walmart online pharmacy</a> best online pharmacy that does not require a prescription [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]pharmacy tech online course[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
adderall online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">reputable canadian online pharmacy</a> wegmans online pharmacy [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]walmart pharmacy order online[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
massachusetts college of pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">publix pharmacy free medicine list</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]sams club pharmacy[/url] costco pharmacy price list 2018

Dec 5, 2019
pharmacy technician jobs near me <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">pharmacy site:costco.com</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]state board of pharmacy[/url] discount pharmacy

Dec 5, 2019
canada pharmacy online <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">florida health care pharmacy</a> arizona pharmacy board [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]fred's pharmacy springfield ky[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
pharmacy tech practice test <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">cvs pharmacy chicago il</a> pharmacy tech salary [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]jewel osco pharmacy[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
target pharmacy hours today <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">canadian pharmacy viagra</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]cvs pharmacy target[/url] french pharmacy products online

Dec 5, 2019
canada pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">wal mart pharmacy services</a> benzer pharmacy locations [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]pharmacy tech[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
fry's pharmacy hours <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">cvs pharmacy san antonio tx</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]nevada board of pharmacy[/url] scripts pharmacy

Dec 5, 2019
new mexico board of pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">kaiser permanente pharmacy</a> heb pharmacy in eagle pass, texas [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]international pharmacy[/url]

Dec 5, 2019
medical park pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">the drug store pharmacy</a> meijer pharmacy login

Dec 5, 2019
hocks pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com ">watkins pharmacy muskegon</a> [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com]primemail pharmacy[/url] wellcare pharmacy directory

Dec 4, 2019
grove pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">mississippi board of pharmacy</a> benzer pharmacy [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]humana walmart pharmacy login[/url]

Dec 4, 2019
maximum dose of cialis https://cialisfavdrug.com all i need is cialis to see alice <a href=" https://cialisfavdrug.com ">black market cialis side effects</a>

Dec 4, 2019
pharmacy manager <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">planet drugs direct pharmacy</a> rite aid pharmacy hours sunday [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]cvs pharmacy bakersfield ca[/url]

Dec 4, 2019
pharmacy technician certification board <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">hot water bottle cvs pharmacy</a> frys pharmacy hours [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]honeybee health pharmacy reviews[/url]

Dec 3, 2019
cvs online pharmacy <a href=" http://canadapharmxpd.com# ">do all saint mary's have a pharmacy</a> national association of boards of pharmacy [url=http://canadapharmxpd.com#]cvs pharmacy clifton nj[/url]

Dec 3, 2019
can you overdose on cialis https://cialisfavdrug.com contraindications for cialis <a href=" https://cialisfavdrug.com ">how long does 20mg cialis keep in system</a>

Dec 3, 2019
though agency cialis cost between drama twice bank [url=http://genericalis.com/]cialis generic tadalafil online[/url] simply article equally invite strange while http://genericalis.com elsewhere opposite http://genericalis.com

Nov 10, 2019